Gartner forecasts released early this week will have confirmed what most CIOs knew and have been struggling with over the last year and a half. The recession has truly hit the IT industry with global spending down six percent to $3.2 trillion in 2009 compared to $3.4 trillion in 2008. When you put it in decimals the change seems small but it is highly significant. The collective fall in spending is the result of a lot of stress and wide scale efficiency initiatives being made by CIOs around the world. Prudence is forcing companies to look at cost cutting across the board and IT budgets have not escaped the spotlight. Gartner predicts IT spending to pick up slowly in 2010 but recent Ovum research provide a bleaker picture until 2013. In short, IT departments are likely to be under pressure for some time yet.
"The full impact of the global recession on the IT services and telecommunications sectors is still emerging, and forecast growth in these areas has been further reduced significantly,” commented Richard Gordon, research vice president and head of global forecasting at Gartner.
While no executives like budget reductions, it appears a forced reassessment of IT efficiencies could turn out to be a good thing. Richard Barker, MD of Sovereign Business Integration, an outsourcing company, sees the downturn as a wake-up call for IT.
“The past decade has been defined by conspicuous consumption across the board. The cheaper goods have become, the more the nation has bought. And the IT department has been one of the biggest culprits in encouraging this ‘pile it high’ culture. Cheap servers, network bandwidth and storage have encouraged inept practices and allowed users to treat the corporate network as an extension of their personal online presence,” commented Barker.
Of course, not all IT departments will have taken this approach, but where it has occurred this kind of profligacy will no longer go on unchecked. Those CIOs that have always erred towards prudence in their IT strategies, will happily continue down their well-planned paths. However, as budget reduction targets hit those less-prepared organisations, big changes will be necessary. So, what are the options for CIO’s to make the changes that matter?
The experts sourcingfocus.com spoke to were adamant that indiscriminate cost cutting is not a sustainable approach. A slash and burn mentality may bring significant cost reductions now but will not stand a company in good stead for the future.
“In past recessions, the ‘soloist’ CIO rapidly cancelled contracts, cut headcounts and really cut into the bone of IT. Companies quickly realised that this was damaging the core of businesses,” comments Myron Hrycyk, CIO of Severn and Trent, the utilities company. “IT is just too central to business for this approach to be viable now,” he adds
Indeed, approaching cost cutting now that IT is so central to the way a company runs, is a highly sensitive task. It seems that the approach can no longer be to simply reduce overheads but must be more of a balancing act of canny expenditure and efficiency in operations.
“CFOs and CEOs are facing a heightened challenge in identifying where to scale back and where to keep investing. This is particularly the case as stringent compliance requirements and cost of failure means cut backs in the wrong areas could be catastrophic,” comments Steve O’Connor, VP of IT transformation at BMC, an IT services provider.
He adds, “As IT is the only integrated function underpinning the entire organisation, it is crucial for business success that CIOs can clearly demonstrate to the board exactly where IT investment is needed, and where the fat can be cut. By doing so the CIO is able to strengthen his/her position as a business leader and can ensure that the business runs as lean as possible, whilst still maintaining success.”
With IT providing the backbone for most large organisations nowadays, it appears the CIO’s moment to truly shine has finally arrived. Clear, decisive and strategic actions could help consolidate his or her rightful place at the board table.
Balancing act in mind, the opportunities for cost cutting are many and a large number of them fairly simple to enact. The budgetary pressures may actually provide an opportunity in disguise, allowing CIO’s to ultimately create a more efficient and effective IT-driven organisation.
sourcingfocus.com asked the industry their top tips on how CIO’s can make positive cost cutting measures:
Consulting costs:
• “n good times, consulting companies made a lot of money from your company. Now it is time for them to share some of the pain. Request a ten percent to 20 percent rate reduction. Make it clear this is temporary – but also that companies who participate will continue to be long-term partners when economic conditions improve with the implicit understanding that not participating in the rate reduction will directly impact the long-term partnership with the consulting company.” Rich Murphy, Executive in Residence, Planview (and ex-CIO at Deutsche Bank).
Applications:
• “Retained support costs can often be reduced. We went to one supplier after realising we only used 60 percent functionality for one system. We proposed to pay them 60 percent of the existing retainer and they went for it.” Myron Hrycyk, CIO, Severn and Trent.
• “Pull together an inventory of your applications, their purpose, and the number of users. You can collect more information but start with the basics, which is easy and low-cost to obtain, and progress from there. This inventory of applications will allow you to identify duplicate, low usage, and low value systems.” Rich Murphy, Executive in Residence, Planview.
Hardware and software:
• “Normal cost reduction measures for hardware are to extend the useable life of the equipment and thus push off the replacement cost. While this works in many cases, it is not always the best alternative. What if the replacement hardware uses 50 percent less electricity requires little to no maintenance, can handle five times the volume, or runs two to three times more efficiently than the old equipment? The total cost may be lower if you decide on a replacement strategy. Plus, hardware providers are also impacted by economic forces, so you should be able to negotiate a reduced price.” Rich Murphy, Executive in Residence, Planview.
• “Look at storage costs and policies, because technology changes in this area over the last few years provides a great opportunity for cost reductions,” Rich Murphy, Executive in Residence, Planview.
Outsourcing partnerships
• “We are no longer ‘soloists’, more part of a band. Work with partners to come to agreements on cost reductions. Our suppliers have an appetite for ensuring Severn and Trent gets the best value from its IT investments. They understand the long-term relationship is more valuable than their short-term margins.
“There are possibilities for reducing blended rates, recalibrating contracts and account management costs. It’s also not unreasonable to ask suppliers to invest in proving the business case for new projects as they will benefit if deals come through,” Myron Hrycyk, CIO, Severn and Trent.
• “Organisations also need to consider options such as pragmatic overhaul of procurement models, redefining “risk and reward” based approaches to managing suppliers, shared services and outsourcing,” David Roots, MD, local government, Civica.
• “At Severn and Trent I have brought IT and procurement closely together so each can more easily adapt to the needs of the business. This is part of our vendor management strategy to enhance vendor relationships,” Myron Hrycyk, CIO, Severn and Trent.
• “I’m a strong believer in multi-sourcing to create the strongest partnerships. The benefits to be gained far outweigh the extra management time involved in such relationships,” Myron Hrycyk, CIO, Severn and Trent.
• “Hidden IT spend is an important area to look at. Those IT expenses that appear in different departments can add-up. CIOs need to get a handle on every IT cost across the organisation,” Steve Wathmought, MD, Xantus, an IT consultancy.
Amid the gloom, there are clearly many opportunities for CIOs to make bold, business enhancing decisions that not only drive efficiencies but also create long-term effectiveness. And, while projections on the arrival of IT industry ‘green shoots’ vary, it is important companies are ready when they do finally arrive.
“If there is one good thing to come out of the recession, it will be that organisations will become far more prudent when it comes to purchasing and managing technology. IT departments may be feeling the pinch. But a return to good, business based IT practices will not only enable organisations to address IT costs today but will stand them in excellent stead as the recession lifts and the economic outlook brightens,” says Richard Barker.
